Pushing the Boundaries of the Essay

What comes to mind when you hear the word “essay”? Maybe you think of a formula for essay-writing that you learned long ago: five standardized paragraphs supporting a single thesis with little room for anything else. Maybe this formula has even given you the idea that essays are a mechanical, rulebound, and unexciting kind of writing. And yet, over its centuries-long history, essay-writing has been anything but formulaic—so much so that scholars find it impossible to agree on a set of stable essay conventions. As the editors of the Edinburgh Companion to the Essay (2022) argue, “the essay” isn’t a unitary genre at all. Instead, it’s a “contested space,” marked by many diverse and even competing approaches. This class is a gateway to that contested space. Assigned readings will introduce you to the outer limits of the essay universe. You will meet writers like James Baldwin, Leslie Jamison, Jacqueline Rhodes, and Cathy Park Hong, among many others, who have all made their own unique mark on the tradition. You will discover writers who make linear arguments—and others who embrace digression, fragmentation, and mosaic structures; those who incorporate research and those who write from memory; those who write in one language and those who draw on multiple languages at once; those who write alphabetically and others who produce multimodal and video essays. Studying this vast range of possibilities will help you expand your own toolkit for when you find yourself writing essays for various audiences and rhetorical situations (including, eventually, senior project proposals, independent study proposals, the Human Ecology Essay, fellowship applications and more). We will mine our readings for the diverse strategies that other writers have used for pulling in their readers, communicating their claims, acknowledging others’ thinking, and creating meaningful structures. You will be asked to reflect metacognitively about how you might transfer these strategies to your own writing in academic, professional, and public contexts. You will come away with an expanded sense of what counts as an “essay,” as well as a sharper capacity to analyze specific essay genres—such as research articles, op-eds, and application essays—each of which comes with its own range of conventions and expectations. Moreover, you will write essays for the exciting and imaginative reasons that have motivated other writers before you: to delve into questions that don’t have easy answers, to explore mysteries, to investigate the world—and yourself. Since essays incorporate so many diverse ways of making knowledge, you will also find a mix of modalities in this class: big-group discussions, collaborative analysis of readings, small-group annotation activities, individual focused free-writing, and more. You will be evaluated on 1) an essay that investigates the work of one essay writer who we will read during the term; 2) a final project (that can be a multimodal piece) in which you enact what you have learned about essayistic writing by composing an essay on an intellectual, aesthetic, or ethical question of your own choosing; 3) participation in a recursive writing process that includes reading, drafting, revision, and responding to classmates’ drafts. This course meets the writing and HS requirements and has no prerequisites.

Course Number
HS1126
Area of Study
Literature & Writing
Course Level
Introductory
Instructor
Valeria Tsygankova